Every practice owner asks this at some point, usually right after a biller resigns or a deposit comes in short. There is no answer that is right for everyone. There is a right answer for your practice, and you can find it with a few honest numbers.
What in-house billing really costs
The salary is the part everyone counts. The full cost is larger:
- Pay and benefits for each biller, including payroll taxes and paid time off
- Software: the billing system, clearinghouse fees and statement costs
- Training: coding updates and payer rule changes every year
- Management time: yours or your office manager's, spent supervising, checking and answering questions
- Turnover: recruiting, weeks of reduced collections while a new hire learns your payers, and the risk that a lot of knowledge walks out the door
Then there is the cost that never appears on a statement: claims that are not followed up because your one biller is on vacation, sick or simply overloaded.
What outsourced billing really costs
Most billing companies charge a percentage of what they collect. The rate depends on your specialty, your volume and what is included.
Look past the rate:
- What is included? Some services stop at claim submission. Denial follow-up, patient statements, old AR and credentialing may be extra.
- Set-up and minimums. Ask about onboarding fees and monthly minimums.
- What is the percentage applied to? Insurance payments only, or patient payments too? Copays collected at your front desk?
- Contract terms. Length, notice period, and what happens to work in progress if you leave.
A lower rate that excludes denial follow-up can cost more than a higher rate that includes it.
Compare results, not just price
The fee matters less than what ends up in your bank account. For either option, look at:
- Net collection rate: of what you were allowed to collect, how much did you collect?
- Days in AR: how long does it take to get paid?
- Denial rate, and how many denials are reworked
- AR over 90 days as a share of total AR
If you do not know these numbers for your practice today, that tells you something about your current reporting.
Five questions that settle it for most practices
1. How many billers do you have? If the answer is one, your revenue depends on one person's health, mood and job satisfaction. That is the most common reason small practices outsource.
2. Can you hire and keep experienced billers where you are? In some markets it is hard. A billing service spreads that risk across a team.
3. Do you want to manage billing? In-house billing needs someone who checks the work, reads the reports and notices when something slips. If nobody wants that job, it will not get done.
4. How complex is your billing? Surgical specialties, workers' compensation and behavioral health each have their own rules. Your biller, or your billing company, needs real experience with yours.
5. How much control do you need? Some owners want billing down the hall where they can ask a question in person. That is a fair preference. A good outsourced team should still give you full visibility and a named person to call.
When in-house is the better choice
- You have two or more experienced billers and low turnover.
- Your numbers are strong and you see them every month.
- Someone in the practice actively manages the work.
If that describes you, do not change something that is working.
When outsourcing is the better choice
- You depend on one person.
- AR over 90 days keeps growing.
- You are opening a new practice and have nobody yet.
- Nobody on your team wants to manage billing.
- You have had billing turnover more than once in two years.
A middle path
It does not have to be all or nothing. Some practices keep charge entry and patient calls in-house and outsource denial follow-up and old AR. Others outsource eligibility and prior authorization so the front desk can focus on patients.
How to decide without guessing
Get your numbers first. Pull an aging report and a denial report and work out the four measures above. If you would like help reading them, we do that at no cost. Request a free revenue audit and we will tell you what we see, including if the answer is that your in-house team is doing fine.
